This Video Violated YouTube’s “Violent Criminal Organizations” Policy

YouTube is a joke.

They’ve deleted this video because it violated their “Violent Criminal Organizations” policy. I’ve uploaded it again with a new title to prove how fucking stupid they are.

For 2 years and 9 months (October 16, 2023 – July 15, 2026), they had no problem with the original upload. Then, out of nowhere – extremist content!

As you can see, the video contains footage of a space battle from the game Mass Effect Andromeda. Wagner’s “Ride of the Valkyries” plays in the background. It’s harmless.

The title, “Israel Attacks Hamas In The Year 3265”, was perhaps not so harmless – but it was supposed to be a dumb gag.

Do you think YouTube cared?

No.

Appeal rejected!

Here’s what they said:

We reviewed your content carefully, and have confirmed that it violates our violent criminal organizations policy. We know this is probably disappointing news, but it’s our job to make sure that YouTube is a safe place for all.

Bull-shit!

Had they reviewed the video “carefully”, they would have restored it, especially since it can be easily proved that they made a moronic mistake.

Note this screenshot:

Here’s the text:

Violent criminal organizations policy at 0:20

Content that intends to praise, promote, or aid violent extremist or criminal organizations isn’t allowed on YouTube. We may make limited exceptions for content with educational, documentary, scientific, or artistic context.

They claim that the problem is at the 0:20 mark.

What’s at the 0:20 mark?

Well, see for yourself. Play the video again.

There’s nothing at the 0:20 mark that “intends to praise, promote, or aid violent or criminal organizations”.

NOTHING.

Since I’m not on X, and Axidava’s X account was banned for no reason, I’ve told Costin to write to @TeamYouTube to sort this out.

Here’s the conversation:

@TeamYouTube Hey, you have taken down one of our videos because it violated the “Violent criminal organizations policy”. The video is footage from the game Mass Effect and it contains no speech. You have automatically rejected the appeal. How is this possible? Please review.

Hi, you should’ve received an email with more details explaining the reason for your video’s removal. If you’ve already appealed and your appeal was denied, this means we took a second look & confirmed that the decision would stand.

It’s an embarrassing mistake on your part. You have taken down a 38-second video of a space battle from the game Mass Effect Andromeda for “Violent criminal organizations policy”. The video contains no speech, just music. Please get a human to review this.

Our team has completed a final review of your vid and the decision stands. Since we’ve shared all relevant details, we can’t provide further updates. We recommend visiting the article we’ve previously shared for more on our community guidelines

Are you kidding me @TeamYouTube? You took down a Mass Effect video because it violated the “Violent criminal organizations” policy. It’s literally gameplay footage of a space battle. Do you even know which video I am talking about? Can I please talk with a human to clarify this?

They never replied after this.

They don’t care.

Usually, @TeamYouTube will ask the user for more details, so that they know exactly which video the user is talking about, but in this case, they said they’ve already “completed a final review” and “the decision stands”.

How can this be?

Pathetic.

My options were the following:

1. Appeal the decision.

I did, and it was automatically rejected. Very suspicious.

Nowadays, you can’t even make your case during the appeal process. You can’t write to them to explain yourself – you just click a button.

And everything is handled by AI.

2. Edit the video.

But they didn’t tell me what to delete. They just showed me the 0:20 mark.

What was I supposed to delete or mute? The 0:20 mark? The part around the 0:20 mark? Or the whole thing after the 0:20 mark?

They didn’t say.

3. Take a policy training.

Which I did.

Sadly, I did. I had no other recourse.

Yes, friends, in the year of our Lord 2026, I took a policy training for a fucking Mass Effect video that YouTube labeled as extremist content.

I’ve never been so humiliated in my life.

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x
Send this to a friend